N
Nico โจ
Awesome work dude! Keep it going ๐
V
Vishal Kadam
helloooooo, good to see you everyday this way its very helpful to understand coolify better. most of my doubts are getting cleared. thank you
J
Jannik Kรถster
hey, for how long are you programming and have you worked at a company before?
A
andreiterecoasa
good morning ๐๐ป
J
Jannik Kรถster
wow, because building something like coolify seems quite complex to me :D
D
daassshh1
hi brooo
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following daassshh1
J
Jannik Kรถster
Does coolify itself run in a docker container?
K
kikoztv
good morning!
M
johntanzer
I was from twitter. Issue with plausible is it is constantly in unhealthy state and totp base 64 32 var is not generated properly.
A
Adith Suhas sv
Hey Bro
R
rahul_gangotri
also can you please see how can we use trigger on arm machines?
A
Anurag Vishwakarma
Hi
R
rahul_gangotri
its not working on my oracle machine
J
Jannik Kรถster
How difficult would you rate the coolify project? And how do you test your features?
T
thijmennl
morning
M
meowhib
Good morning
M
johntanzer
Last time also worked for me env. But was unhealthy
M
meowhib
Funny how I start my work day with you
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following stormannsgalskap
M
meowhib
I am a cat yes
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following emogiraffe450
E
emogiraffe450
Good morning supreme leader ๐ซกโค๏ธ
J
Jannik Kรถster
but how can you manage new docker containers from within your coolify instance that also runs in docker? That is quite magic for me :D
M
meowhib
Quick question, do you use any software to track what you need to work on on coolify?
R
rahul_gangotri
i identify as server
S
StoryWithLight Photo
Can you please add synology docker manager support?
M
johntanzer
Also original domain name was saved as the env fqdn even after I changed it, surely should auto change?
E
emogiraffe450
Can every app be ported as a docker image?
S
stormannsgalskap
i use Coolify 3 and i wanted to thank you. I like it very much. I just saw the message in Discord and decided to come by.
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras You did it!! I got myself the Announcement roles PogChamp
S
ShadowArcanist
Linear da best!!!
M
meowhib
Cool, I also started using LInear and it's going too well. Even for personal things not just projects
A
Adith Suhas sv
mongodb
T
ThimoDEV
Heyyy Good morning all!
S
StoryWithLight Photo
Installing coolify on a synology doesnโt work ( synologyโs docker UI called โcontainer managerโ). Would be easier to manage projects/deployments on synology with coolify. Thanks for all of your efforts!
S
StoryWithLight Photo
I filed issue #2370 detailing error
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following summeeeR
D
duarte_oc
You pinged everyone
S
StoryWithLight Photo
*2730
D
duarte_oc
That's why I',m here ahah
D
duarte_oc
Worth it though ;)
S
stormannsgalskap
me too, glad to be here
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following migliorosso
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following duarte_oc
M
migliorosso
Hello, what's the best way to migrate coolify to another vps?
S
summeeeR
are you an expert in docker?
S
StoryWithLight Photo
Thank you
D
duarte_oc
Instant bookmark lol
D
duarte_oc
Glad I came
M
migliorosso
Thank You!
S
stormannsgalskap
Is there a 3 to 4 migration planned?
S
StoryWithLight Photo
Have you considered adding ntfy (ntfy.sh) support in the future?
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras you don't have to change any permissions for the role. Just create the role without any permissions and let people get roles. So when you ping the role, people who have the role will get pinged SeemsGood
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following JONASdufg
S
ShadowArcanist
<3
D
duarte_oc
This looks like a great stream Andras - really appreciate the work on coolify. Made my whole setup much better
D
duarte_oc
Now I need to work on my own things though ahah - talk later!
S
summeeeR
what is the most used web app hosted with coolify? im guessing nextjs?
S
StoryWithLight Photo
Ntfy for notifications
M
meowhib
@summeeeR I think so too, since people are fed up with vercel
J
JONASdufg
I spent 10hrs trying to set up plausible with your instructions but it did not work... ๐
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras that only one metric is enough for us
T
thoo_0224
I also had trouble with setting up plausible, but coolify also has a built-in service called umami which I'm using right now.
M
MonsterzDotA
How does the feedback button work Andras? Does it create you tickets or send an email to be looked at?
S
ShadowArcanist
@thoo_0224 same here
M
MonsterzDotA
That's interesting thanks
S
ShadowArcanist
I have a seperate discord server for notifications like Coolify related stuffs, website uptimes, VPS resource usage alerts etc.. it's a nice to have one Kappa
J
Jannik Kรถster
why went from node to php?
S
ShadowArcanist
nice! (i'm not a telegram user xD)
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras Streaming on twitch is going well so far, so Tutorial videos on YouTube when? Kappa
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following Seiik4tsu
S
stormannsgalskap
and for the frontend? what do you use?
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras I'm waiting for the youtube videos Kappa
S
stormannsgalskap
thanks
S
Seiik4tsu
Hey Andras, was wondering if coolify can be used as docker image only without the ability to modify the host machine? Would like to host it locally on my unraid system and use hetzner servers for the deployments. ๐
S
stormannsgalskap
i code in symfony, we don't ha
T
ThimoDEV
How long did it take you to learn the php way of working coming from javascript?
S
Seiik4tsu
Haha alright, thank you! Thought coolify might have 'support' out of the box for this use case as it creates docker networks, the traefik proxy and stuff.
V
Vishal Kadam
/team/admin is accessible for a user with member role and also able to delete owner. which is not secured
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras yup, friday here also! the evening looks spicy to do a prod release without doing any testing LUL
G
Grizgold
Kappa
H
hugodos
Then release a half baked PR statement on monday
H
hugodos
Kappa
S
ShadowArcanist
@hugodos LUL LUL LUL
T
thijmennl
best to do on friday :P
T
ThimoDEV
You could release it with some special caution of use? or would it affect cloud users too?
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following eej000
E
eej000
where are you based from?
T
ThimoDEV
ohhhhh yeah then its risky for those who dare auto update Kappa
E
eej000
watching from Philippines
S
Seiik4tsu
What is the test coverage of coolify? Wouldn't it give you a lot more security if it ran through automations like github release + actions?
G
Grizgold
test ? Kappa
S
Seiik4tsu
LUL
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following mohammacl
M
mohammacl
hey hey
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following moaath0_0
C
CodingMariusz
Andras, I installed Coolify on my Hetzner server yesterday. It's a really nice product. Thank you so much for your hard work. Will send you some ๐ฒ via OpenCollective!
G
Grizgold
i had some trouble with traefik yesterday :( i switched to caddy and manually created a proxy file and now it works flawlessly
H
hugodos
Are you the sole core maintainer?
M
mokiwara
hello, may i ask you a question how soon should i start learning DSA in my learning journey
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following danielcodex
M
mohammacl
have you decided on the new UI u mentioned twitter?
S
skullsplitter23
data structures & algorithms
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following AximCore
G
Grizgold
i installed stirling pdf and it worked fine, but when i enabled stirling's auth it completely broke :( i only got error 404 with everything running, restarted etc. tried reinstalling like 5 times but it never worked, switched to caddy and it was working in 2 minutes
A
AximCore
Szia, akarom mondani, Hi! :D
M
moaath0_0
Hello , how could i begin in game dev because there isnโt any source to learn you how to begin in it what are you recommend for me?
H
hugodos
@moaath0_0 Go to "develop dot games" website
M
mohammacl
i think DSA should become second nature in your mind. you can always look things up but the intuition is the thing that is most important
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following Grizgold
V
vishalkadam472
/team/admin is accessible for a team user with member role and also able to delete owner. which is not secured
E
eej000
what tech stack ur using before?
M
mokiwara
i see, thank you all :)
T
ThimoDEV
@skullsplitter23 For me what works is to read the SOLID principles guide, then if you find yourself going to write a lot of if statements or inefficient long code you can search if your problem has a suiteable design pattern to use
H
hugodos
develop dot games
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following CodingMariusz
M
mohammacl
thor
M
mohammacl
piratesoftware
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras learn it on the go is the best way to learn stuffs because we won't stuck in Tutorial HELL and we won't learn stuffs that are not needed for us <3
S
Seiik4tsu
What where the reasons for you to chose php? I would like to contribute but the last time I touched it was 5 years ago. What else could be contributed?
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following herkulanu
M
moaath0_0
thank you ๐
G
Grizgold
i only used php for like a week when i was 12 LUL now it's python all the way
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following lc_fd
H
hugodos
in the end it doesnt _really_ matter on the language just whatever your productive in
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras can you explain how actually Coolify cloud works -- like what are the process behind it etc..?
H
hugodos
Excalidraw
N
Niki2k1
or tldraw
S
ShadowArcanist
LUL
B
Boeterbrod
Good morning!
E
eej000
why postgres and not mysql?
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following sw0bu
S
sw0bu
GM
B
Boeterbrod
mysql is owned by Oracle, yea? Of course everyone will hate it
H
hugodos
Same as working in both mysql and postgres, I just had a way better experience with postgres
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras Thanks!
E
eej000
so in total you have 5 servers?
B
Boeterbrod
For me when I was first learning relational databases I was using MySQL Workbench. It for some reason did not display any buttons that were necessary to link tables together. I checked their issues and they just simply refused to fix it. Hated anything MySQL ever since.
B
Boeterbrod
We still have to bring our own server if we opt for coolify cloud right?
H
hugodos
And its managed, so support alone is worth way more value than $5
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras this one is a genius idea ngl. Would love to hear more explanations from you on different topics <3
B
Boeterbrod
The way you do it is great tbh, hosting is too much trouble that will take you away from development
S
StoryWithLight Photo
If I have multiple coolify instances on two rpiโs, can they be linked together with cloudflared with one being primary?
S
sscarduzio
BTW all this "SLA" responsibility thing, it only depends on what you make people sign. You can create a EULA that discharges all responsibility.
B
Boeterbrod
I do like reaction videos but honestly I like watching you work in Laravel. I'm at the level where I'm still grasping at the essentials and Laravel seems great to work in
S
sscarduzio
About vendor lock in: not an issue in the moment you allow for custom servers
G
Grizgold
no love for Django? BibleThump
H
herkulanu
Could you do a video tutorial or talk about Healthchecks with a dockerfile. It's been my biggest pain with Coolify :)
S
sscarduzio
now that you tested Laravel, do you think django would have been equivalent/better/worse choice?
B
Boeterbrod
Tutorials would be great tbh.
G
Grizgold
you can use htmx with django
B
Boeterbrod
livewire, is it like react?
S
ShadowArcanist
LUL LUL LUL LUL LUL LUL
B
Boeterbrod
Hey don't judge, I'm a noobie
G
Grizgold
react is pain
B
Boeterbrod
LUL
B
Boeterbrod
That seems very convenient
B
Boeterbrod
So instead of JS only ecosystem, it is PHP ecosystem all the way if I understood it correct
E
eej000
does coolify has REST API ?
E
eej000
for example i want to execute command using API not the coolify Portal?
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following frendly
F
frendly
o/ hey yw
C
Cinzya
good morning
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras Yes
C
CodingMariusz
Yup. I can fully understand you.
H
herkulanu
You're doing well!
L
lc_fd
You are doing more than enough!
B
Boeterbrod
I think your stream is a breath of fresh air to me, I got tired of twitch months ago due to everyone I watch being so fakely over enthusiastic. It is good to watch someone down to earth working on proper projects
T
terrig6
does coolify user docker under the hood?
B
Boeterbrod
en thu sias tic
F
frendly
i want to watch you precisely because you are not "fake" enthusiastic like other streamers
B
Boeterbrod
Trust me it gets tiring to watch people speak in caps lock
N
nidaliciousgg
agree with the above
E
eej000
your doing great job!
G
grapplingdev
LDSWC looking nice and low today
B
Boeterbrod
Considering you've been at it for a week or so, it is amazing progress just keep at it
E
eej000
simple man, doing great things
E
eej000
thats why your coolify
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following nipakke
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following vishalkadam472
G
grapplingdev
I think that counts as "lets do some work"
V
vishalkadam472
I have noticed in the v4.0.0-beta.318 https://example.com/team/admin ( Admin View ) is accessible for a user with `member role` and also able to `delete owner`. which is not safe
G
grapplingdev
Look, I don't make the rules ok NotLikeThis
T
ThimoDEV
You would do great making youtube videos, I feel like it would be something like fireship informative, but more focused around the topics of coolify :)
A
Adiology
yo
N
nft_scam
the only problem I have with hertzner is that they only have server in Germany & finland
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following evocati13
S
ShadowArcanist
@Adiology you are late to the PARTY!!!! Kappa
A
Adiology
@ShadowArcanist I was eating nmpSpin
S
ShadowArcanist
@Adiology SeemsGood
C
crocotentin
Hello ! I just realize that using the dev setup create a folder in the root file system under /data, not sure if it's a best practice for dev env
A
Adiology
I agree with that tbh
S
Seiik4tsu
Hetzner also has servers in the US @nft_scam at least for the cloud servers
A
Adiology
@Seiik4tsu US-East
A
Adiology
and West too now I think
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following selnapenek95
S
Seiik4tsu
Yep
A
Adiology
Similar to redux
A
Adiology
but obviously Laravel does it better
N
nft_scam
@Seiik4tsu ahh I see, still waiting for Singapore tho, pretty rough out here, we had to use contabo.
A
Adiology
Singapore would be great
A
Adiology
I do not trust any cheap host besides Hetzner
A
Adiology
also Netcup is not bad
A
Adiology
but they're too old school
N
nft_scam
ooo imma check that out
A
Adiology
8GB 6vCore for 7 EUR
C
Cinzya
speaking of domains, if I want to add a domain that is not the wildcard to a application, do I need to point my DNS to a specific port on coolify for that so it only points to the specific application?
P
P0RANT
hi
H
hugodos
@Cinzya DNS is simply IP resolution, as long as coolify knows the domain the reverse proxy should handle the host header
A
Adiology
@hugodos Exactly
C
Cinzya
@hugodos gotcha
A
Adiology
I think the best thing happened to self hosting was LetsEncrypt
B
Boeterbrod
I will eventually switch to Hetzner probably but the service I use right now is too good to me. I pay around 6 eur with tax I get 4 vcpu and 8gig ram
A
Adiology
@Boeterbrod Which host?
B
Boeterbrod
Webtropia
A
Adiology
Never heard but if they're good then why not
B
Boeterbrod
They are Germany based. Not bad at all
A
Adiology
I used to use Netcup for 3 years, most people don't even know what it is but is another German hosting
H
hugodos
@Adiology LE was a big step forward to opening SSL certs for everyone not pay walling it, even though companies still use them
A
Adiology
@hugodos People who pay wall SSL are so dumb
P
P0RANT
@HeyAndras How do you think is it possible for me to find any job as a programmer without any experience? I was working on some of my small projects for years now. Built my home server p0rantOops
C
Cinzya
@Boeterbrod how come you want to switch then?
A
Adiology
@P0RANT I was able to get my first job as an engineer based on my side projects!
H
hugodos
@Adiology There are "benefits" technically but they are very niche
B
Boeterbrod
@Cinzya Well because everyone uses Hetzner and they swear by it. If I have to scale I think it would be the better option.
P
P0RANT
@Adiology wow nice to hear that!
A
Adiology
@hugodos Not something most people would care for, as long as my data is encrypted E2E, I don't care
H
hugodos
@Adiology Exactly
L
lucian222
How important are projects in the current market if I want to land an internship?
N
nft_scam
@P0RANT same here, I used to work as cashier, and work on side project on the side, landed a job as machine learning engineer.
H
hugodos
@lucian222 Being active in your free time, shows the company you are willing to learn and expand your own knowledge. Plus also learning "how to learn your way" helps yourself know how best you upskill
B
Boeterbrod
Where I am (Belgium) people seem to care way more about certificates and such rather than projects.
B
Boeterbrod
So it might differ from country to country
B
Boeterbrod
I would not want to be in the US job market. 1000 applicants per opening. Sheesh.
N
nft_scam
yea crazy
H
hugodos
Plus funding is different country to country. It makes a big different if government give incentives to companies to take "risks"
A
Adiology
I'm Indian, people care for certificates here too but its all about how you present yourself and how skilled you are when applying to companies which are not Fortune 500
C
Cinzya
@Boeterbrod oh good to know. What kind of certificates do companies look for? currently looking for Frontend / Fullstack entry position in the Netherlands right now.
A
Adiology
EU is definitely more difficult from what I've seen
B
Boeterbrod
@Cinzya If you are looking for work in Flanders, better brush up on your Java. Other than that they almost always ask for a bachelor's degree in CS or equivalent. I guess you can convince them with projects but I'd say unlikely lol
L
Learner
Hi!! I want to contribute to this. How can I do that?
H
hugodos
Hey andras, I opened a discussion questions which was a feature request / current implementation question. Should I just wait until I get a response as I see your current focus is bugs rather than feature requests.
C
Cinzya
@Boeterbrod I see. I studied Multimedia and Communication in Germany with a focus on Web Development and Web Design. I learned Java in Uni but I hated it lmao Might give a try again then
A
Adiology
@Cinzya Java is more backend focussed and not very beginner friendly, i'd suggest starting with JS or Python then diverging into what you like. It's important to learn fundamentals of programming first regardless of a language, then you can use anything
B
Boeterbrod
@Cinzya There are definitely React jobs and even Django jobs if you look hard enough but React ones ask for ridiculous things. I even saw a listing that asked for 53+ years of React experience. (Obviously a typo but that's the level lol)
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras speaking of discord.. just now I remembered I sent you a DM today for discord improvement and management stuffs Kappa
H
hugodos
No worries, I work for another open source project CrowdSec, we are a security product than helps self hosters secure instances. The question I opened was about coolify authentication logs.
S
ShadowArcanist
@HeyAndras Np <3
A
Adiology
Good idea, we're breaking records on viewership today nmpPOGGERS
S
ShadowArcanist
I permanently mute the servers that ping everyone LUL
C
Cinzya
@Boeterbrod appreciate the insights! Yeah ive seen a few of those already, haven't actively started applying though. Ever since my last company had to close down, I've been doing a lot of freelance work, but I would prefer a fulltime salaried job again at some point.
S
ShadowArcanist
we are 1 follower away from reaching 400 followers
T
ThimoDEV
@ShadowArcanist I mute all servers except my own and coolabs HarleyWink
A
Adiology
~50 viewers on Twitch
S
ShadowArcanist
@ThimoDEV LUL
A
Adiology
25 more for partnership
A
Adiology
PepePls
A
Adiology
yes you can only show Twitch
S
StreamElements
Thank you for following P0RANT
A
Adiology
If only a big streamer raided Kappa
A
Adiology
PogChamp
B
Boeterbrod
@Cinzya I hope you find something good! After I graduate my bootcamp I'm also going to look for salaried job because freelancing in Belgium is a horrible experience LUL
A
Adiology
You should make these counters with StreamElements and link them to a command so I can increase them nmpKEK
B
Boeterbrod
Andras, what password manager do you use? I'm using keepass but I find it a little clunky at times so I'm seeking alternatives
A
Adiology
@Boeterbrod Bitwarden
A
Adiology
you can also self-host it
B
Boeterbrod
Oh sweet, thanks
A
Adiology
Idk what he uses, i'm just saying it's a good option
C
CascaveldeRodape
Cheap Viewers on xxofm.top/kkzp
C
Cinzya
Bitwarden is amazing. loved it every since i started using it
A
Adiology
@Cinzya Ever since LastPass went to trash, I moved to BitWarden and it's been great
H
hugodos
@Adiology Same
B
Boeterbrod
I'll check bitwarden because I'd rather self host :D thanks
A
Adiology
@Boeterbrod Vault Warden server + Bitwarden Client
B
Boeterbrod
What do you know, it is a service on Coolify :D
B
Boeterbrod
That's gonna be super easy to whip up
A
Adiology
No one noticed I did my first ban in this chat nmpEZ
A
Adiology
A scam/phishing link
B
Boeterbrod
@Adiology Think again
A
Adiology
Andras is LIVE on PartyHat https://x.com/heyandras PartyHat https://youtube.com/@heyandras PartyHat https://twitch.tv/heyandras PopNemo
V
ViskaliX
Any specific reason why you aren't using RegEx for the shared environment variables?
A
Adiology
I also reported that person, they're now banned on Twitch completely nmpKEK
V
ViskaliX
I still can't fully understand RegEx and I know I always do the "dumb way" as you said yourself, too complicated for me
C
crocotentin
Do you not use docker networks inside of the services ? Is there any good reason why ?
C
crocotentin
I was looking trough the docker compose in the templates, and I didnt find services using networks. Was curious if it's added later
H
hugodos
need '/g' to not stop after first match?